eject cd doesn't work and "just should"
Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
linux (Ubuntu) |
Invalid
|
Low
|
Unassigned |
Bug Description
When I press the button on my CD/DVD drive the CD doesn't eject. This is a bug. I don't care if it's mounted. I don't care if it's use. When I press that button, it should come out. I understand that forcefully unmounting a file system is in general a bad idea. Data can be corrupted, be lost or disappear into thin air -- but not on a read-only mount of a read only CD.
I shouldn't have to hold down the button. I shouldn't have to reboot my computer. Xine shouldn't lock up because I wanted my disc and neither should mplayer. They should exit gracefully and my disc should come out so that I can throw it on my desk full of other randon crap.
I shouldn't have to fight my CD-drive.
If I put in a scratched or otherwise damaged disc (unbeknownst to me) there should be some timeout period where it gives up and stops trying to mount it -- this makes things hang. It's annoying.
Give me back my disc.
Please, thanx :-)
tags: | added: karmic lucid |
tags: | added: maverick |
tags: | added: natty |
Changed in gnome-mount (Ubuntu): | |
status: | Confirmed → Incomplete |
I sympathise with the initial reporter... yes, CD/DVD-drives can give grief to the user in Linux, and I have faced this issue myself (hence marking as confirmed). Ubuntu BTS (and most probably a number of others) contain a few reports against particular programs (like Nautilus) that sometimes prevent the ejection of a disc. Sometimes the command "eject" won't work, but "sudo eject" will, sometimes you have to repeat the "sudo eject" a few times, sometimes start by killing a stray process that was left behind preventing the ejection etc. See also bug #66609.
"I shouldn't have to fight my CD-drive." ;-) Indeed, ejecting media, especially read-only media, shouldn't be as hard as it sometimes seems to be.
But how to tackle this issue, that's the difficult question...