bug-buddy does not integrate with an Ubuntu bug tracking system
Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
bug-buddy (Ubuntu) |
Invalid
|
Medium
|
Sebastien Bacher |
Bug Description
Scenario: A user is doing something in GNOME, and blam! Program
floozeblubber or whatever has crashed. A helpful "Inform Developers"
button appears. Great!
The template bug report in bug buddy is not so great. It asks for
"Expected Result". Well, I expected floozeblubber not to crash, didn't
I? "Actual Result"? It just crashed, duh -- you told me it crashed a
few dialogs ago!
I also asks "How often does this happen"... It's possibly the first time
it's happened, but maybe it'll happen everytime, or never again. I'm
reporting just in case, so the traceback won't be lost. Of course, I'm
not necessarily sure if "this" is -- is this a new bug in epiphany, or
the same crash I saw last week?
These sorts of difficult-to-answer questions are likely to put off
prospective bug reporters. Many people are aware that free software
developers have a reputation for being ruthless to inadequate bug
reports, so if they feel they can't properly answer the questions, they
might not bother at all. Or perhaps they'll just look at the list of
questions, and simply shrug and think "too hard", and discard the crash
dump report. After all, they were almost certainly in the middle of
doing something.
My experience with Mozilla's "talkback" feature has been more positive
-- it makes it clear that it's sending debug info to developers, and
that any extra information about what you were doing that you provide
would be helpful, but not necessarily vital, and failing all else it
helps them gather stats about where the most common crashes are. i.e.
even if you can't explain anything about why it happens, your crash
report is still valuable.
Perhaps this would be solved by some slightly more friendly
instructions than:
"""
Please make your bug report in English, if possible.
Summary
___________
Description
Description of Problem:
___________
___________
...
"""
?
e.g. "Please describe what you were doing when this crash happened,
in English if possible." And then just leave the "description"
box completely empty, rather than asking *six* questions, a couple
of which just don't seem to make sense (see comments about "Actual
Result", etc).
I don't think that bug-buddy is properly functional on Warty anyway; this
information probably doesn't even go anywhere.
When it does become fully supported and active, we will still want to be more
exclusive about the bug reports that we receive, because we don't have a system
to process otherwise-useless bug report data at this time.