Comment 20 for bug 46520

Revision history for this message
Nemes Ioan Sorin (nemes-sorin) wrote : Re: [Bug 46520] Re: Grub installs to wrong drive's MBR in default install. No way to change in standard installer.

OK - tanks - than take it as a proposal -> Why - Ubuntu must adapt dinamic
to changes - then - a lot of let say advanced Linux users on other areas -
wil to the same mistake like me - writing menu.lst by hand ..so the proposal
is for a script -> to check other valid lines that are not generated by
Debian Automatic Kernel script -> then move to outside with the mension "
Those valid ( valuable lines ) were moved outside of automatic generated
zone - to prezerve your customisation against future kernel upgrades. Your
customisation was not afected."

This way a potential enemy can be killed from start - even a people like me
wrote lines on the "hot" area. Mo more complaints for "nothing", low trafic
on mailing lists ;) ...etc - so please consider my proposal.

Anyway please read again the first message from this list - I dont know why
but I feel it is unsolved by now...

2008/9/13 Mackenzie Morgan <email address hidden>

> > the point is that an kernel upgrade ( so an Ubuntu upgrade ) will
> > rewrite your boot menu, even is customized - your problem can be from
> > menu.lst too ( but sure ..can be from the wrong MBR location as you
> suggest
> > here )
>
> It rewrites *only* the Debian Automatic Kernel section, based on
> whatever rules you specify above. Make your changes only in the one
> location up top where the settings go.
>
> > My menu.lst was customized but an recent upgrade rewrite my menu.lst so
> for
> > next boot I can't see my XP installation on grub list so I need to repair
> my
> > menu.lst by hand. This is a potential bug too
>
> No it's not. It explicitly says not to edit between the Debian
> Automagic Kernel lines. The Windows info should be outside of that
> area--either before it begins or after it ends. Only that area is
> rewritten.
>
> --
> Grub installs to wrong drive's MBR in default install. No way to change in
> standard installer.
> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/46520
> You received this bug notification because you are a direct subscriber
> of the bug.
>

--
Nemes Ioan Sorin