Comment 36 for bug 1770532

Revision history for this message
Christian Ehrhardt  (paelzer) wrote :

Hi Neustradamus,
the initial bug was reported as "Upon upgrading to bionic, amavisd-new DKIM signing no longer works." so no one thought about former releases.
This also matches that there were no bugs about that issue, prior to Bionic being released.

Also there is an increased risk the further changes are backported.
In this case all >=Bionic was on 2.11, but Xenial is 2.10 and Trusty even on 2.7.
So even if it happens in older versions the tradeoff between regressions for current users vs the benefit of the fix for others might be different.
Especially with a somewhat dead upstream and a patch that existed in three variants - also the test instructions are ok'ish but not totally complete to try it in different variants. Therefore the risk is too high to apply it further back (IMHO).

The old patch applies, but with a 788 line offset in a 34k line perl file - oO

For now - for me personally - this is Won't Fix, but I'm open to be convinced if we get enough confirmation and confidence in it. So if you really think the very same issue affects Xenial, please share some details about why you think so. Do the testing steps above trigger it for you, if you can add extra details about testing if needed for Xenial.