Comment 1 for bug 252345

Revision history for this message
tricky1 (tricky1) wrote : Ubuntu Raid implementation looks like mockery

On Hardy all distros (including server!) do not correctly implement Raid 1 together with crypted partitions or lvm.

The whole installation process requires a well thought out strategy taking into consideration that the initramfs of a degraded system might be inappropriate and that it is not possible to create a new image before the system is up again...

With degraded arrays it all depends on the type of raid.

For raid 1 (mirroring) the user might well decide to continue booting (automatically or after manual confirmation?).

For other raid types this is high risk, but in some special cases might be necessary.

See also bug Bug 33649 pending for more than 2 years.