Comment 18 for bug 1835114

Revision history for this message
Balint Reczey (rbalint) wrote :

@raharper I agree with the concern regarding the manipulation of sshd config. To minimize the collision with cloud-init this package does not change /etc/ssh/sshd_config like cloud-init does, but overrides the configuration value with a systemd drop-in. The drop-in is placed at the time the AMI is built thus there is no race with cloud-init here, and if upgrade of ec2-instance-connect has a race with cloud-init then there is a race with the potential upgrade of sshd as well.

Regarding the potential user confusion when the user also sets ssh keys using cloud-init eic_run_authorized_keys is designed to _merge_ the keys used by Instance Connect with the other keys in use thus the users can continue to use their keys deployed by cloud-init or the ones deployed by other means.

I also agree that there is additional overhead for each ssh connection, but while testing the package I have not found that excessive. We may need further evaluation of the impact on the ssh service before adding the package to the AMIs by default, but I think this can be done after finishing the MIR process.

Upstream already answered @paelzer's caching proposal, and the package is installed on Amazon Linux 2 by default already, thus I believe upstream's attention is warranted regarding the overhead.