please revert startup sounds
Affects | Status | Importance | Assigned to | Milestone | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ubuntu-sounds (Ubuntu) |
Invalid
|
Undecided
|
Ubuntu Artwork Team |
Bug Description
I hope this is the right package to report this on. The startup sounds in Edgy are nowhere near as nice as the ones we had in previous releases. I don't want to disrespect the author, who I think did a good job considering it was (as I understand it) a community contribution, but the old sounds were much more relaxing, professional and above all *memorable*. Also, they didn't have any corny symbals in them. Can we have them back?
I think keeping the startup sound consistent will improve the marketing of Ubuntu as an operating system - people will associate it with the sound, just as they do with Windows.
I remember the interview with Mark that was shown on English TV focused on the (old) startup sound as something that users might be hearing more and more in place of the annoying Windows startup sound.
Changed in ubuntu-artwork: | |
assignee: | nobody → ubuntu-art |
Changed in ubuntu-sounds: | |
status: | New → Invalid |
While one can discuss the merits of the sounds on aesthetic grounds, I would like to address the latter portion of your comment.
Currently, the modern world moves at the speed of thought -- it changes, it morphs, it is nebulous. It is possible that an operating system that strives to be contemporary and modern should _perhaps_ attempt to permit such metamorphosis.
I wholeheartedly agree with you that consistency is worthy of concern, but I believe the current branding of Ubuntu serves that purpose -- without focusing on the minutiae. The consistency is constructed from the cohesive sum of the whole, not the discreet partial elements. Where the technology within Ubuntu can change quite dramatically, we should permit for the possibility of the same on aesthetic functionality.
Ultimately, change is healthy. We will certainly make mistakes in the process, but that is the nature of innovation. Our operating system should strive to push new limits, set new standards, and, most importantly, change at the rate that society is changing. That is part of the beauty of it.