Comment 25 for bug 214119

Revision history for this message
Jordan Crouse (jordan-crouse) wrote :

1) Attach your X log and we can be sure that you are using the resolution that the monitor reported. This is one of many problems with DDC/EDID. People don't realize that there isn't a connection between what the display controller can do, what the monitor can do, and what the monitor reports that it can do. When you chose to use DDC, then you are blindly restricted to what the monitor tells you to use. You *can* use other resolutions, but that will involve hacking an xorg.conf file.
2) Xorg -configure works from the GIT tree, so the driver and the X server agree on probing the PCI ID at least. I'm not sure how the detection and installation works in Ubuntu, so somebody more knowledgeable then myself will need to evaluate that.
3) That is kernel based breakage - it has nothing to do with the X driver
4) Ditto.

Unfortunately, this patch _is_ our simple workaround - all other workarounds are far more complex. But I do agree this patch needs more far more testing - it is still some time away from being added to the GIT repository, let alone making it into any distros.