Gnucash does not handle HBCI correctly

I just built a new package with HBCI fixes from gnucash svn in my PPA :
deb http://ppa.launchpad.net/saivann/ubuntu intrepid main

Testing and feedback is needed, can you install this package and report all improvement or regressions? Thanks!

Please add a hardy version too.

hardy version added to my PPA

Hello Saïvann,

the patched version from your repo works as expected!

-Marc

Marc Schiffbauer : Thanks for your feedback.

Norbert and everybody : Can you give more feedback on that package?

Am Montag, den 22.09.2008, 21:43 +0000 schrieb Saïvann Carignan:

> Marc Schiffbauer : Thanks for your feedback.
>
> Norbert and everybody : Can you give more feedback on that package?
>

I wont have time to test it before Thursday - but then I'll be glad to
provide some feedback.

Hello Saivann,

the Error-Messages with HBCI are gone. But I have to accept the certificat form my bank each start of gnucash.

Thanks for your feedback. Since all feedback so far are positive that the patch fixes the problem, I set this bug as a duplicate of bug 269725 and ask for the patch to be included in intrepid (sorry for the mess).

Norbert : Great that the patch fixed it. For the bank certificate issue, can you open a new bug report for gnucash and report the problem upstream (gnome.bugzilla.org) ? Many thanks.

Hi Saïvann,

I am sorry, but I think this is NOT a duplicate of bug 269725 ... the problem described in bug 269725 is something totally different that I had seen too.

This bug here is about a communication issue between aqbanking and gnucash which made gnucash always think there has been an error after a banking transaction when it succeeded in some cases. This has been fixed with the svn-diff I told you.

Now bug 269725 is about a message the informs the user about an additonal information in the hbci-response which is handled in a confusing and misleading way by gnucash. The bugreport describes exactly what I saw too and what is indeed confusing and annoying.

-Marc

This bug was fixed in the package gnucash - 2.2.6-2ubuntu2

---------------
gnucash (2.2.6-2ubuntu2) intrepid; urgency=medium

  * debian/rules: Add dpatch patchsys.
  * debian/control: Add dpatch build-depends.
  * debian/patches: Add r17502 and r17543 upstream patches to fix current
    issues with HBCI. (LP: #269725) (LP: #269686)

 -- Saivann Carignan <email address hidden> Tue, 23 Sep 2008 21:38:39 -0400