SuperTux 0.3.0 is officially unsupported!

Bug #84084 reported by DJ Wings
6
Affects Status Importance Assigned to Milestone
supertux (Ubuntu)
Fix Released
Undecided
Alexandre Vassalotti

Bug Description

Binary package hint: supertux

According to the SuperTux mailing lists at lethargik.org, SuperTux 0.3.0 is unstable, and may cause severe performance problems on some computers! The solution, which Debian has already embraced, is to maintain a SuperTux 0.1.3 package, which is thoroughly tested, alongside a SuperTux 0.3.0 package.

Changed in supertux:
assignee: nobody → avassalotti
status: Unconfirmed → Confirmed
Revision history for this message
Sarah Kowalik (hobbsee-deactivatedaccount) wrote :

Thanks for your lovely talk on your mailing list.

Presumably we'll have to remove this completely from the archives, as a start, then sync the debian version from unstable across (note that debian experimental has 0.3.0 as well)

Revision history for this message
Sarah Kowalik (hobbsee-deactivatedaccount) wrote :

(As there's no way to downgrade a package - the archive will reject a lower version number than what's already there.)

Revision history for this message
StefanPotyra (sistpoty) wrote :

please note that 0.3.0 is in edgy-backports as well.

Revision history for this message
anonym (launch-mailinator) wrote :

I should maybe point out that "DJ Wings" is in no way affiliated with the SuperTux project, although his/her posts on the Wiki and the Mailing List might make people believe otherwise.

Citing from the release notes, "SuperTux 0.3.0 [is] a preview of SuperTux Milestone 2 [... and] is by no means complete, but the game is already fun to play."

So, having it in the unstable/experimental branches of distributions is great, because that's just what it is: An unstable/experimental version meant for playtesting the engine and for doing compatibility testing.

My advice for stable branches would be to ship it as a separate "supertux2" package, because 0.3.0 will grow up to be Milestone 2, a version incompatible with SuperTux MS1 and with vastly different hardware requirements.

Please don't let some angry users deter you from keeping up the good work. The rest of the world appreciates what you're doing :-)

Revision history for this message
DJ Wings (djwings) wrote : Re: [Bug 84084] Re: SuperTux 0.3.0 is officially unsupported!

"Angry users"?
I was merely making a point that SuperTux 0.3 may fail to run, or run
unplayably slowly, on several computers, a point acknowledged several times
on the SuperTux mailing lists. Besides, the wiki disapproves of
shipping 0.3with distributions, and Ubuntu is no exception. Why don't
you read them?
SuperTux 0.3 is unsupported, unstable, and, in several cases, unplayable.
As for not being affiliated with SuperTux: That is completely false. I have
contributed a new version of the "Salsa Con Carne" theme, beta-test, keep
the wiki clean, and have even created a character for the game. What have
you done that allows you to anonymously attack me on the mailing lists?

On 2/24/07, anonym <email address hidden> wrote:
>
> I should maybe point out that "DJ Wings" is in no way affiliated with
> the SuperTux project, although his/her posts on the Wiki and the Mailing
> List might make people believe otherwise.
>
> Citing from the release notes, "SuperTux 0.3.0 [is] a preview of
> SuperTux Milestone 2 [... and] is by no means complete, but the game is
> already fun to play."
>
> So, having it in the unstable/experimental branches of distributions is
> great, because that's just what it is: An unstable/experimental version
> meant for playtesting the engine and for doing compatibility testing.
>
> My advice for stable branches would be to ship it as a separate
> "supertux2" package, because 0.3.0 will grow up to be Milestone 2, a
> version incompatible with SuperTux MS1 and with vastly different
> hardware requirements.
>
> Please don't let some angry users deter you from keeping up the good
> work. The rest of the world appreciates what you're doing :-)
>
> --
> SuperTux 0.3.0 is officially unsupported!
> https://launchpad.net/bugs/84084
>

Revision history for this message
DJ Wings (djwings) wrote :

"Angry users"?
I was merely making a (quite valid) point that SuperTux 0.3 may fail to run, or run unplayably slowly, on several computers, a point acknowledged several times on the SuperTux mailing lists. Besides, the wiki disapproves of shipping 0.3 with distributions, and Ubuntu is no exception. Why don't you read them? SuperTux 0.3 is unsupported, unstable, and, in several cases, unplayable.
As for not being affiliated with SuperTux: That is completely false. I have contributed a new version of the "Salsa Con Carne" theme, beta-test, keep the wiki clean, and have even created a character for the game. What have you done that allows you to anonymously attack me out of the blue like this?

Revision history for this message
DJ Wings (djwings) wrote :

Ignore the duplicate entries.

Revision history for this message
Alexandre Vassalotti (avassalotti) wrote :

A new package has been included in Ubuntu Feisty called `supertux-stable'. It contains the stable 0.1.3 version of SuperTux. Also, the `supertux' package has now a notice in its description warning that it's the beta version, and bugs should be expected.

Changed in supertux:
status: Confirmed → Fix Committed
Revision history for this message
DJ Wings (djwings) wrote :

Thank you for your efforts. This was the solution that most people involved with this issue had been hoping for, and, in my opinion, the best one.

Revision history for this message
StefanPotyra (sistpoty) wrote :

supertux-stable is now in the repositories.

Changed in supertux:
status: Fix Committed → Fix Released
To post a comment you must log in.
This report contains Public information  
Everyone can see this information.

Other bug subscribers

Remote bug watches

Bug watches keep track of this bug in other bug trackers.